Skip to content

Mary Sutter’s Civil War

April 13, 2011

This week marks the 150th anniversary of the outbreak of the War Between the States—the war between brothers—and a war in which the technology of warfare outgunned the technology of medicine. It is this latter aspect of the war that Robin Oliveira makes the focus of her debut novel.

My Name is Mary Sutter, by Robin Oliveira


Mary Sutter, a skilled mid-wife by trade, is denied entry into medical school because she is not a male. She falls in love with a handsome young neighbor, but she is not pretty enough, and he becomes enamored with her beautiful twin sister. Paradoxically, the door that opens opportunities for Mary is the  same one that ends the lives of so many others, The Civil War. And during the young country’s struggle to hold itself together, Mary strives to old herself together as well. Mary leaves her home in Albany, New York to answer Dorthea Dix’s call for nurses in Washington  DC, where she is again rejected—this time because she is not old enough. Due to sheer determination and persistence, she falls under the tutelage of two separate surgeons, who both fall in love with her, but more importantly, help her pursue her dreams. But sometimes you must be careful what you wish for…

The writer’s attention to historical details and her seamless weaving of fact and fiction makes the war come to life in this instant Civil War classic. I had to go take a shower to wash the gunpowder out of my hair.

A Favorite Passage:

The author helps to demonstrate the dire state of medicine—as well as supply lines—in the mid 19th  century with the following lines of dialogue between Mary and Dr. Stipp during the early days of her work with him,

“This one can’t breathe.”

“Give him whiskey.”

“This one can’t walk.”

“Give him whiskey.”

“That one can’t stop itching.”

“Give him whiskey.”

“This one has got diarrhea.”

“Haven’t they all?”

“We’ve run out of quinine.”

“Give oil of turpentine.”

“We’ve run out of turpentine.”

“Then boil some willow bark and put it in whiskey and give it to him.”

“We’ve run out of whiskey.”


The strong female character of Mary Sutter will put you under her spell—just as she cast one on Dr. William Stipp, Dr. James Blevins and the hospitals and battlefields full of men who grow to worship her.  Although completely rounded with necessary human foibles, Mary casts a long shadow and one cannot help but admire her courage, pluck, chutzpa, tenacity and will to both survive and succeed. I haven’t met a character this compelling since Jeannette Wall’s Lily in Half Broke Horses.  Be prepared to fall in love with Mary Sutter.

Whether saving babies, “sorting soldiers” (you’ll have to read the novel to know what I mean here) or sewing up amputees, Mary embodies the struggle of the “women of the nation who braved disease, despair, devastation and death to nurse in the Civil War hospitals…Nearly twenty women became physicians after their experiences nursing in the Civil War…” as described in Oliveira’s acknowledgements.

In addition to Dorthea Dix, we encounter the personal side of other real-life characters such as President Abraham Lincoln, his secretary, John Hay, and Clara Barton. But the author adds them for authenticity, not to take the focus off Mary’s story.

Mary’s family—in addition to the aforementioned pair of doctors—serves the role of rounding out the cast of characters—especially her mother, Amelia, who is a strong presence.


The author plays with Paradox and Irony. For example, showing how doctors used the carnage of war as an opportunity for research and practice of their craft and technique;  and how patients were more likely to die of dysentery, or secondary infection than from their original bullet wounds. She also deals with the struggle between Personal vs. Professional allegiances; issues of Family, Love, and Loyalty; Grief, Despair and Hope; and War, Politics, and Military Strategy. Overarching themes include Gender Roles and Medicine. The latter being defined as much by what that body of knowledge did not encompass (such as washing hands between patients) as by what it did (which was theoretically and not practically taught in medical schools.)

Why Book Clubs will Love it:

Of course, one of the reasons book clubs love historic fiction is because you can learn so much about history when following a story of a compelling
character. Book Clubs will enjoy not only revisiting the well-known stories of the Civil War, but also gobbling up the well-placed background details and
motivations of those who fought it. All of the themes outlined above will make for fine discussion.

My Name is Mary Sutter has just been added to Charles Frazier’s Cold Mountain , Margaret Mitchell’s Gone with the Wind, and Geraldine Brook’s March as one of my all-time Civil War fiction favorites!




My Name is Mary Sutter, by Robin Oliveira

Penguin Books

Historical Fiction

ISBN: 978-0-14-311913-5

Author Interview

Reading Group Guide available

7 Comments leave one →
  1. April 13, 2011 12:55 pm

    The city of Roswell (Georgia) did chose this book for their Roswell Reads program earlier this year… I led a discussion of the book for them – and everyone really got into it. A great read – and lots to discuss!

    — Dana

    • April 13, 2011 5:08 pm

      Great News! I’m putting this one on our short list for Woodland Reads 2012! LOVED the book. The author is from Seattle—did Roswell have her visit?

  2. Robin permalink
    April 15, 2011 11:59 am

    Roswell did have her visit. They were a gracious and attentive audience. And thank you for this lovely review–so kind!

    • April 15, 2011 12:50 pm

      Robin: How great! We just wrapped up our One City, One Book event last week. I’m sure we’ll be starting the selection process all over again for next year. Glad to have some quality nominees—LOVED your book! Cheers! BCC

  3. Drew permalink
    November 16, 2011 1:19 pm

    Thank you for a wonderful review. As you may know, MNIMS is being awarded the Michael Shaara Prize for Excellence in Civil War Fiction this weekend at Gettysburg College.

    • November 16, 2011 3:04 pm

      Drew: I was not aware of that—but I must say the award is very well deserved. I’ll have to check it out—thanks for the tip!
      Cheers! BCC


  1. Silly Saturday: or October Month-end Madness « Book Club Cheerleader

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: